They say time heals all wounds, but clearly, time has never met a married couple with trust issues. One minute, everything is alright, but the next, you’re staring at your spouse across a candlelit table, wondering whether your heart ever fully recovered from that “one big mistake.”
The truth is that relationships are messy, human hearts are fragile, and gifts won’t heal wounds. This is the reality of today’s Original Poster (OP), whose husband had an affair years ago. However, despite all that time, she realized she never really forgave him, and this led to a confession that left him shattered.
More info: Reddit
RELATED:Infidelity and broken promises can turn trust into a fragile vase glued back together, but forever handled with care and doubt
About 10 years ago, the author’s husband cheated, and she moved out, but discovered she was pregnant, leading them to reconcile
Over the years, she worked long hours and relied on her husband for support, but built emotional walls to protect herself from future pain
On their 15th anniversary, the husband celebrated with gifts, dinner, and heartfelt words, unaware of her heartache
She then confessed that while she loves him, she still fears betrayal and her love isn’t the same as before, leaving him shocked and devastated
In the following days, she saw her husband crying privately, which left her struggling with guilt and uncertainty about whether their marriage is salvageable
Ten years ago, the OP’s husband cheated, and she left him only to discover she was pregnant. She believed that having her husband’s support was much better than hiring a nanny or babysitter, so they reconciled, and for a while, it looked like they’d beaten the odds.
However, she threw herself into work, all while building impenetrable walls around her heart to guard against future hurt. Though her husband promised the infidelity was a one-time mistake and that he had remained faithful afterward, she still couldn’t sleep beside him without fear and anxiety.
On their 15th anniversary, her husband presented her with a diamond bracelet and a homemade dinner. He also expressed his love for her and their life together, but for the OP, the years of buried pain boiled over and she couldn’t believe he had been obliviously happy. After her husband’s declaration of love, she confessed that she couldn’t say the same.
She admitted that she had been living in fear, anxious that she would find him betraying her again. After that, in the days that followed, her husband cried quietly, privately, and often. She, in turn, felt guilty for “breaking him,” unsure if honesty had been healing or cruel.
To gain insight into whether it’s possible to love a partner but still struggle with trust years after reconciliation, We reached out to marriage counsellor and infidelity recovery specialist Mildred Okonkwo, who explained that this scenario is actually more common than most people realize.
“Trust, unlike love, isn’t automatically restored just because a couple reconciles, no. It’s rebuilt piece by piece over time,” she said. “Someone can genuinely love their partner while still feeling cautious or hesitant, especially if past betrayals were deep or complicated.”
We then asked what steps are most effective in rebuilding trust after infidelity, and Okonkwo had this to say: “Rebuilding trust is gradual and mostly relies on consistent actions, clear communication, and patience from both partners.”
She also stressed the importance of radical honesty from the partner who betrayed the trust, explaining that transparency about actions, whereabouts, and feelings, coupled with consistent reliability, is essential.
Curious about when a relationship might be beyond repair, we asked Okonkwo how to tell if reconciliation is realistic. “First off, repair is possible. Relationships that can still be healed usually show at least some willingness from both partners to communicate openly, take responsibility, and work on rebuilding trust and intimacy,” she explained.
Conversely, warning signs that a relationship may be beyond saving include “repeated betrayals, persistent dishonesty, refusal to take responsibility for harm, or complete emotional withdrawal. If the pain and resentment consistently outweigh connection and hope, it’s often a signal that the relationship may not survive despite love or history,” she noted.
Netizens encouraged reflection and personal choice, stressing that forgiveness and communication are crucial for moving forward. They also advised therapy, honest conversations, and evaluating her needs, noting that while her husband clearly regrets his actions, the next steps are ultimately in her hands.
What would you do if you were in the OP’s shoes? Would you stay in the relationship or walk away? We would love to know your thoughts!
Netizens empathized with the author, but insisted that she have an honest conversation with her husband
